The science of trust: What makes people believe, engage and act?

Trust shapes whether people believe a message, engage with an organisation and ultimately take action. This blog explores the signals that build trust, from clarity and social proof to transparency and consistency, and what they mean for brands, campaigns, websites and services.
Claire Headshot BW
Written by
Claire MacDonald, Creative Director
Date
05/10/2026
Related services

Trust is one of those things we tend to notice most when it disappears.

A customer hesitates before entering their card details. A resident ignores an important public health message. A potential client visits a website, looks around and leaves. A community disengages from an organisation asking them to change their behaviour.

Different situations. But the same underlying question:

Do I trust you enough to act?

Trust can sometimes be treated as a vague brand quality, something organisations hope to earn through good design, reassuring language and a strong reputation.

Behavioural science gives us a more useful way to think about it.

Trust influences how people interpret information, judge risk, respond to uncertainty and decide whether engaging with an organisation feels worthwhile. That means it isn’t simply something communications should say. It is something the entire experience needs to demonstrate.

And if we want people to believe, engage and ultimately act, understanding how trust works.

Trust reduces uncertainty.

Every decision involves some degree of uncertainty.

Can I believe this information? Will this organisation do what it says? Is this service safe? What happens if I make the wrong choice? Will my information be treated responsibly?

The greater the perceived risk, the more important trust becomes.

Research into trust has often distinguished between perceptions of ability, benevolence and integrity. In simple terms, people are making judgements about whether an organisation is competent, whether it has their interests in mind and whether it behaves according to principles they consider acceptable.

Those judgements may not be consciously articulated, but they can shape behaviour.

A technically brilliant organisation that appears indifferent to its users can lose trust. So can an organisation with good intentions but poor delivery. Likewise, saying the right things while behaving inconsistently can quickly undermine credibility.

Trust therefore needs both competence and character.

For organisations, that creates an important challenge. You cannot simply tell people that you are trustworthy.

You have to give them reasons to conclude it for themselves.

We look for signals.

People rarely have all the information they would need to evaluate an organisation objectively.

Instead, we use signals.

Professional design might suggest competence. Clear contact information can suggest accountability. Independent accreditation provides evidence that claims have been scrutinised. Testimonials can demonstrate that other people have taken the same decision successfully.

None of these signals proves that an organisation is trustworthy on its own. Together, however, they help people make decisions under uncertainty. This is why apparently small details matter.

A broken link. An unexplained claim. An outdated page. A confusing form. A hidden fee. An inaccessible process. An inconsistent message. Each can create a moment of doubt. And moments of doubt accumulate.

The opposite is also true. Consistency between what an organisation says and what people experience can strengthen trust over time.

Social proof helps us navigate uncertainty.

When we are unsure what to do, we often look to other people.

Reviews, testimonials, case studies, recommendations, professional endorsements and evidence of widespread participation can all reduce uncertainty.

This is the behavioural principle of social proof.

But responsible use matters.

There is a meaningful difference between showing genuine evidence of other people’s experiences and manufacturing the appearance of popularity.

Good social proof is specific, relevant and credible.

Instead of:

“Our clients love working with us.”

Evidence might show:

  • what problem a client was trying to solve
  • what was done
  • what changed
  • how the outcome was evaluated
  • what the client experienced along the way

For public-sector campaigns, social proof can also take the form of community participation, trusted local voices or evidence that a behaviour is becoming normal within a relevant peer group.

The important word is relevant. People are more influenced by the behaviour and experiences of groups they identify with than by an abstract crowd.

Male and female marketer sat side by side, looking at a laptop together

Familiarity can make decisions feel safer.

We tend to feel more comfortable with things we recognise.

Psychologists have studied this through phenomena such as the mere exposure effect, where repeated exposure can increase familiarity and, under certain conditions, positive evaluation.

This helps explain why consistency matters in communications.

If your visual identity changes dramatically between channels, your tone sounds completely different from one interaction to the next, or your campaign messaging feels disconnected from the service people eventually encounter, you introduce uncertainty.

Recognition reduces some of that cognitive work. This doesn’t mean repeating the same advert until people surrender. It means creating a coherent experience.

Your brand, website, social content, campaigns, customer service and real-world interactions should feel like different expressions of the same organisation.

Clarity is a trust signal.

Complexity creates effort;  when people have to work hard to understand what an organisation means, what it wants from them or what will happen next, uncertainty increases. That has practical consequences.

Behavioural frameworks such as EAST, emphasise making desired behaviours Easy, Attractive, Social and Timely.

Making something easy isn’t only about convenience.

It can support trust too.

Consider the difference between a service that explains:

“Submit your details and we’ll contact you.”

and one that explains:

“Complete this three-minute form. We’ll email you immediately to confirm we’ve received it, and a member of the team will respond within two working days.”

The second reduces ambiguity. People know what is required, what happens next and when to expect it.

Trust and COM-B.

The COM-B model proposes that behaviour occurs through the interaction of Capability, Opportunity and Motivation.

Trust can influence each.

If people do not understand information or find it difficult to assess whether a claim is credible, psychological capability may become a barrier.

If a service is inaccessible, difficult to navigate or provides few opportunities for reassurance, opportunity may be constrained.

And if people are worried about risk, suspicious of the organisation or unconvinced that acting will benefit them, motivation can suffer.

This is why simply increasing awareness is often insufficient. Someone can know perfectly well that a service exists and still choose not to use it.

The behavioural question isn’t only:

“Have they seen our message?”

It is:

“What needs to be true for this person to feel able, willing and confident enough to act?”

Trust may be an important part of that diagnosis.

Transparency matters, particularly when things go wrong.

Organisations sometimes behave as though trust requires perfection. It doesn’t. In many situations, pretending everything is perfect can be less credible than acknowledging uncertainty or limitations.

Transparency can mean explaining why information is being requested, how personal data will be used, what a service can and cannot provide, what evidence supports a claim, or where uncertainty remains – it can also mean admitting mistakes.

Trust is strengthened when expectations and reality align. When they don’t, organisations have a choice: hide the gap or address it. Accountability is itself a trust signal.

For public bodies, charities and purpose-led organisations, this is especially important. People are not only judging the message. They may also be judging whether an institution deserves authority, access to information, public funding or permission to influence behaviour.

Responsible communication therefore requires more than persuasive effectiveness. It requires ethical effectiveness.

Behavioural science can be used to make communications more effective. But effectiveness alone isn’t enough. Dark patterns, manufactured urgency, hidden defaults and misleading social proof can all influence behaviour but that doesn’t make them responsible.

If an organisation uses behavioural insights to exploit cognitive biases, it may achieve a short-term conversion while damaging long-term trust.

The better question is not:

“How can we make people do this?”

It is:

“How can we create the conditions in which people can confidently make an informed decision?”

That approach respects autonomy while still recognising that the way choices are presented affects behaviour.

Trust gained through manipulation is fragile. Trust earned through consistent, transparent and responsible behaviour is far more valuable.

What organisations can learn.

If behaviour change is the goal, awareness alone is rarely enough.

Effective interventions help people answer:

  • When exactly will this happen?
  • What will trigger the behaviour?
  • What action should follow?
  • What barriers might get in the way?

In practice, this means designing communications, services, and campaigns that support action planning rather than simply encouraging intention.

The most effective behaviour change strategies don’t just persuade people to care, but help people act.

Markers in a meeting, sat around a table chatting

What this means for campaigns.

A campaign asking people to change behaviour should consider trust from the beginning, not add a reassuring message at the end.

Ask:

Who is delivering the message?

  • Does the audience consider that person or organisation credible?
  • What previous experiences shape their response?
  • Which concerns or uncertainties might prevent action?
  • Can claims be supported with evidence?
  • Could trusted community voices play a role?
  • Does the behaviour being requested feel realistic and achievable?
  • And importantly, does the experience after someone responds to the campaign reinforce the promise made by the communication?

A brilliant campaign leading to a frustrating service creates a trust gap. Communications and service design cannot be separated.

What this means for brands.

Brands often talk about trust as an aspiration.

“We want to be a trusted partner.”

And how do you become one? Ask:

What would make someone believe that?

Trust might be demonstrated through transparent pricing, accessible expertise, professional standards, independent accreditation, evidence of results, honest case studies, responsive communication or consistency between promises and delivery.

Brand strategy should identify those behaviours and signals, not simply find more persuasive ways to make the claim.

Your brand isn’t only what you say about yourself.

It is the collection of expectations you create, and whether people’s experience confirms them.

What this means for websites.

A website is often where trust is tested. Within seconds, visitors may be making judgements about professionalism, relevance, credibility and risk. Good design matters, but visual polish alone is not enough.

A trustworthy digital experience might include:

  • clear navigation
  • accessible language
  • transparent pricing or processes where appropriate
  • genuine case studies and testimonials
  • evidence behind important claims
  • recognisable credentials and partnerships
  • clear privacy information
  • accessible contact details
  • inclusive and accessible design
  • clear explanations of what happens next

What this means for services.

Sometimes the biggest trust problem isn’t communication at all – it’s the service.

If people are asked to provide the same information repeatedly, don’t know what happens next, cannot speak to a human when something goes wrong, encounter inaccessible systems or receive contradictory information, no campaign can completely compensate for that experience.

This is where behavioural science benefits from systems thinking.

Behaviour doesn’t happen inside an advertising campaign. It happens within environments, processes, relationships and institutions.

If we want different behaviour, sometimes we need to change those conditions rather than simply change the message.

Designing for trust.

So, what makes people believe, engage and act? There is no single behavioural trick.

Trust emerges from an accumulation of experiences and signals: credibility, competence, consistency, transparency, familiarity, social evidence, clarity and the sense that an organisation will behave responsibly.

That is precisely why trust should not be left solely to the communications team. It needs to exist in the strategy, the service, the interface, the evidence and the behaviour of the organisation itself.

We believe effective communication starts with understanding behaviour. That means looking beyond what people see and asking what helps or prevents them from acting.

Because the goal isn’t simply to get attention. It’s to create the conditions for people to make confident, informed choices, and to build trust that lasts.

Behavioural insights

Let’s turn evidence
into impact.

If you’re interested in collaborating, whether through research, professional education, or applied behavioural science, we’d welcome the conversation.