When someone has experienced harm, the decision to engage in restorative justice is rarely straightforward.
It is not simply a question of understanding what restorative justice involves or knowing that support is available. For many people, the decision is shaped by a complex combination of emotions, experiences, relationships and perceptions of safety.
Will I be listened to? Will my experience be taken seriously? What happens if I change my mind? Can I trust the process?
These questions matter just as much as the information someone receives.
During Restorative Justice Week, we are reflecting on the human factors that influence people’s willingness to consider restorative justice, and why trust, empathy and genuine choice must sit at the heart of how we communicate about it.
Understanding is important, but it is not enough.
Restorative justice offers opportunities for people affected by harm to communicate, directly or indirectly, with those responsible, where appropriate and with the support of trained practitioners.
It can provide space for questions to be asked, experiences to be acknowledged and the impact of harm to be explored. But participation is deeply personal, and it will not be the right choice for everyone.
From a behavioural science perspective, providing information is only one part of supporting someone to make a decision.
The COM-B model of behaviour change suggests that behaviour is influenced by three interacting factors: capability, opportunity and motivation.
Applied to restorative justice, this helps us recognise that knowing a service exists, and understanding how it works, does not necessarily mean someone feels ready or able to engage.
A person may understand the process but feel emotionally overwhelmed. They may be interested in participating but lack confidence in the people facilitating it. They may want answers but worry about the consequences of reopening difficult experiences.
These are not simply barriers to overcome. They are legitimate concerns that deserve to be understood and respected.
Effective communication must therefore do more than explain restorative justice. It must recognise the psychological and social factors that shape how people perceive the opportunity to participate.
Trust begins with psychological safety.
For someone considering restorative justice, trust is fundamental.
Trust in the practitioners involved. Trust that their experiences will be respected. Trust that appropriate safeguards are in place. And trust that the process will not expose them to unnecessary harm.
Psychological safety, in this context, means helping people feel able to ask questions, express concerns, communicate their boundaries and make decisions without fear of judgement or pressure.
It is not about promising that the process will be emotionally easy or free from discomfort. Difficult conversations can be an important part of restorative justice. Rather, it is about creating the conditions in which people feel informed, supported and able to exercise control over their involvement.
Communication plays an important role in establishing these conditions.
Clear explanations, transparent expectations and sensitive language can help reduce uncertainty. Equally, acknowledging that people may have concerns, or may not wish to participate, demonstrates respect for their experiences.
Trust is not created through reassurance alone. It develops when what people are told is consistent with what they experience.
For restorative justice services, this means ensuring that communications accurately reflect the support, safeguards and choices available throughout the process.
Empathy means recognising different experiences.
No two people experience harm in exactly the same way.
Personal circumstances, previous experiences, cultural backgrounds, relationships and emotional responses can all influence how someone feels about restorative justice.
An approach that feels empowering to one person may feel uncomfortable or inappropriate to another.
This is why empathy must be more than a reassuring tone of voice. It requires a genuine effort to understand people’s perspectives, needs and concerns without making assumptions about how they should feel or respond.
In practice, empathetic communication recognises that people may experience conflicting emotions. Someone may feel curious about restorative justice while also feeling anxious. They may want to understand why something happened without wanting direct contact with the person responsible.
These responses can coexist.
Language that acknowledges this complexity can help people feel understood, rather than directed towards a particular decision.
For example, there is an important difference between telling someone that restorative justice will help them move forward and explaining that it may offer an opportunity to ask questions or communicate the impact of harm, if they feel it is right for them.
The second approach respects uncertainty and avoids promising an outcome that cannot be guaranteed.
Empathy also extends to how we represent people who have caused harm, recognising the importance of accountability while avoiding language that reduces individuals to a single action or experience.
Ultimately, empathetic communication is about recognising the humanity of everyone involved, without minimising the seriousness of harm.
Genuine choice is essential.
One of the most important principles of restorative justice is voluntary participation.
People should be able to make informed decisions about whether to take part, what form their involvement might take and whether they wish to continue, within the safeguards and arrangements of the process.
This principle also has a strong foundation in behavioural science.
Self-Determination Theory identifies autonomy as a fundamental psychological need, highlighting the importance of feeling that our actions reflect our own choices rather than external pressure.
In restorative justice, supporting autonomy means ensuring that people have the information, time and space they need to consider their options.
It also means recognising that choosing not to participate is a valid outcome.
Crucially, support should not be dependent on participation. Someone considering restorative justice may need reassurance, practical guidance or access to specialist services, regardless of whether they ultimately decide to engage with the process.
This is where clear signposting becomes particularly important. Communications should help people understand not only what restorative justice involves, but also where they can turn for further information, advice and appropriate support, whether they choose to participate, decline or simply need more time.
Making support visible and accessible demonstrates that people’s wellbeing matters independently of the decisions they make. It also helps create the conditions for genuine choice, ensuring that individuals do not feel they must commit to a particular course of action to receive help.
Communications should never imply that someone has a responsibility to engage, that participation demonstrates greater strength or forgiveness, or that declining an opportunity represents a missed chance for recovery.
Even well-intentioned messaging can create pressure if it presents restorative justice as the expected or preferred response to harm.
Stories of positive experiences can be powerful, but they must be handled carefully. When success stories are presented without context, they can unintentionally create unrealistic expectations about what participation will achieve.
Restorative justice does not guarantee closure, forgiveness, reconciliation or a particular emotional outcome.
Responsible communication should make this clear.
The aim is not to persuade as many people as possible to participate. It is to ensure that those who may benefit from restorative justice can understand their options, access appropriate support and make a decision that is right for them.
What this means for behaviour change communications.
At MacMartin, we believe meaningful behaviour change begins with understanding people, not simply delivering information.
Our approach combines behavioural science with creativity to explore what influences decisions, what creates barriers to engagement and how communication can support positive, informed action.
But in sensitive contexts such as restorative justice, the definition of a successful communication campaign requires particular care.
Success should not be measured solely by how many people respond to a message or express an interest in participating.
We must also consider whether people feel informed, respected and supported in making their own decisions.
This includes recognising that providing access to support and signposting can be a valuable outcome in its own right. A person who chooses not to participate in restorative justice, but leaves with a clearer understanding of their options and where to find help, has still benefited from responsible communication.
This is where responsible behaviour change practice becomes especially important.
Using behavioural frameworks such as COM-B can help us identify the factors influencing engagement, but those insights must be applied ethically. Understanding what motivates someone does not give us permission to exploit their emotions, vulnerabilities or uncertainties.
Instead, behavioural insight should help us reduce unnecessary confusion, improve accessibility, build justified trust and support genuine choice.
Creative communication has an important role to play, too. Thoughtful storytelling, inclusive language and accessible design can make complex or sensitive information easier to understand.
However, creativity must always serve the needs of the audience, rather than prioritising emotional impact at their expense.
In restorative justice, the most effective message is not necessarily the one that generates the strongest reaction. It may be the one that helps someone feel sufficiently informed and supported to make their own decision.
Putting people before participation.
Restorative justice reminds us that meaningful engagement cannot be separated from the conditions in which decisions are made.
Trust takes time to build. Empathy requires us to listen without assumptions. And genuine choice depends on people feeling free to say yes, no or not yet.
During Restorative Justice Week, it is worth reflecting on how we communicate opportunities for restorative justice, particularly with those who may be experiencing uncertainty, vulnerability or distress.
Are we creating understanding, or simply raising awareness? Are we building trust through transparency, or relying on reassurance? Are we empowering people to make informed choices, or unintentionally encouraging a particular outcome?
These questions extend beyond restorative justice. They speak to a wider responsibility for everyone working in communications, public services and behaviour change.
Responsible communication is not about influencing people at any cost. It is about using insight, empathy and creativity to help people make informed choices, with their dignity, autonomy and wellbeing at the centre.
And sometimes, the most meaningful outcome is not a change in behaviour, but a person feeling genuinely empowered to decide what happens next.